Prophetic Telegraph

Arthur Eedle's Home Page

Menu
  • Home
  • Series
      • Latest Series
      • The Wellspring 2017

      • The Prophetic Telegraph
      • The Prophetic Telegraph 2014
      • The Wayside Pulpit
      • The Wayside Pulpit 2015 – Another series of brief articles to foster thought on a variety of subjects.
      • The Wellspring
      • The Standard
      • The Restitution Times
      • Recognising the Hand of Judgment
      • Resurrection and Change
      • Before He comes
      • The City of God
      • Seekers Corner
      • God’s Spoken Word
      • The Song of Solomon
      • Simple Statements on Serious Subjects – Evangelistic tracts for use in outreach work. First used them back in 1987 and now brought up to date for extended use.
      • Prophecy considerations
      • The Millennial Octave
      • All our Yesterdays
      • Mysteries of Science & Faith
    • Close
  • Books
      • Albion Restored
      • Arithmetic of Creation
      • Cathedral
      • Flood Tide
      • Full Cycle
      • Hidden Treasures
      • Into His Hands
      • King’s Fountain
      • King’s Fountain Omnibus Edition
      • Restoring the Honour of His Name
      • Seven Steps To Bethlehem
      • Shiraz meets Jesus
      • Showdown
      • Susans Journal – Omnibus Edition
      • The Caxton Conspiracy
      • The Last Days
      • The Periodic Table of the Elements
      • The Prophetic Telegraph
      • Unless the Lord build the House
      • Unless the Lord builds the house – Vol. 2 eBook
      • Unless the Lord builds the house – Vol. 2
    • Close
  • About Arthur
  • Statement of Belief

Chapter 17. Judas Iscariot

12th June 2015 by Arthur Eedle

The career of Judas Iscariot is compassed about with perplexities, at least by traditional exegesis. But let’s have a look at the texts concerning him.

John 6:64-65 “‘There are some of you who do not believe.’ (For Jesus knew from the beginning the ones who were not believing, and the one who was to betray Him.) And He said, ‘Therefore I told you that no one can come to me unless it has been given to him of the Father.'”

John 13:2 “And supper being ended, the Devil put it into the heart of Judas Iscariot, son of Simon, to betray Him.”

Matthew 26:24 “The Son of Man goes, as it is written of Him, but woe to that man through whom the Son of Man is betrayed. It would be good for that man if he had not been born.”

Here is a case of apparent predestination to betrayal, and its awful consequences. How does that square with the character of God? The simple answer is, it doesn’t. As students of Scripture, we cannot afford to allow ungodly thoughts to determine the meaning of what we read, even if at first reading it seems paradoxical and unjust.

On the basis of Judas Iscariot’s pre-existence, something must have happened to cause this scenario. Let’s take stock of the situation. Judas was Ish-Kerioth, that is, “man of Kerioth”, a town in Judaea. Jesus had chosen nearly all His disciples from around the Lake of Galilee. Judas was the exception. No doubt he prided himself that he, and he alone, could boast of being a Judaean, like his Master. This can be learned from the Gospels.

But what can be learned from his pre-existence days? Hardly anything, except what may be based on Jesus’ words about Judas, that “it would have been better if he had not been born.” The Gospel of Mark, in the A.V. unfortunately says “never been born,” which is not in the Greek. In fact the Greek of Matthew and Mark is identical in this reference.

Why would it have been better for him not to be born? The word “not” is OU in Greek, and is the intensive form of the negative, differing from ME, which is not so strong. Hence the Master was saying “it would have been better if he had not been born.” Therefore there was something about his birth in that place and at that time which militated against his best good. Jesus was saying in effect that his birth was contrary to the Father’s will at that time.

We can only say therefore that Judas must have asked the Father to be allowed to be born at that time, and to become a disciple of Jesus. This was his great wish in life, and he imagined that God would be pleased with such a request. He was crest-fallen when the answer given him was “No, it will not be to your best good.” But Judas must have argued, and having been told several times that it would be better for him to be born later, he still insisted. Eventually, God said to him, “Be it then according to you will. But I have warned you. No good will come of it.”

This being so, Jesus knew about this decision when He chose Judas, hence the words, “Jesus knew from the beginning who it was who would betray Him.”  He was to be allowed to attain his greatest wish, and become a disciple of Christ. But during those three and a half years he became more and more disillusioned. Imagining himself to be a great ambassador of the Christ when He entered His Kingdom, he found the Messiah talking about crucifixion, and asking His followers to take up their crosses to follow Him. What merit was there in that? He wanted a military-style Messiah, who would eliminate the Roman tyrant from the land. Instead he found a foot-washing, woman-and-child loving man, who spoke about lilies of the field, sparrows, and widow’s mites. He learned to despise Him, and eventually decided to betray Him into the hands of the authorities. Why? To save Him from Himself! To prevent Him from being made a fool of, and being tortured and crucified by the Romans.

But it backfired on him badly, because no sooner had he played his part, he realised that he had betrayed innocent blood. But it was too late. In utter remorse he went out and committed suicide.

This is the only way in which a just and proper understanding of Judas’s actions, and Jesus’ choice, can be explained. If Judas had never existed until he was conceived or born, then the events of his life would forever remain a mystery, compassed about, perhaps,  by dark thoughts towards God Himself.

Filed Under: All our Yesterdays Tagged With: Human Pre-Existance

About Arthur Eedle

Arthur was born in 1931, and became a Christian in 1948. At London University he gained a 2nd honours degree in Physics. He went on to get a Teaching Diploma, and throughout his career life taught physics in England, Kenya, and Hong Kong. Coupled with his love of science, he was a keen student of Greek and Hebrew, and gave many lectures on Biblical subjects. Read more

All our Yesterdays

Chapter 1. The Man born Blind

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 2. The Festival of Creation

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 3. The Feast of Trumpets

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 4. Born wicked

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 5. Born to Election

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 6. Wheat and Tares

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 7. Jacob and Esau

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 8. The Return Home

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 9. Of gods and men

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 10. Coming into the World

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 11. The Blood of Abel

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 12. The Treasury of Souls

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 13. Made Together

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 14. Memory

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 15. Wisdom’s rejoicing

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 16. Redemption

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 17. Judas Iscariot

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 18. A Root of Bitterness

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 19. Predestination & Foreknowledge

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 20. Ancient Jewish Beliefs

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 21. Ancient Christian Beliefs (1)

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 22. Ancient Christian Beliefs (2)

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 23. Ancient Christian Beliefs (3)

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 24. Apocryphal writings

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 25. Plato’s writings (1)

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 26. Plato’s writings (2)

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 27. Plato’s writings (3)

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 28. George Ritchie’s experience

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 29. Betty Eadie’s experience

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Chapter 30. Conclusion to this Series

12th June 2015 By Arthur Eedle

Article Series

  • All our Yesterdays (30)
  • Before He comes (13)
  • God's Spoken Word (37)
  • Mysteries of Science & Faith (8)
  • New Series (101)
  • Newsletter (2)
  • Original Series (109)
  • Prophecy considerations (5)
  • Recognising the Hand of Judgment (33)
  • Resurrection and Change (16)
  • Seekers Corner (14)
  • Simple Statements on Serious Subjects (6)
  • The City of God (18)
  • The Millennial Octave (23)
  • The Restitution Times (22)
  • The Song of Solomon (6)
  • The Standard (19)
  • The Wayside Pulpit (107)
  • The Wayside Pulpit 2015 (96)
  • The Wellspring (101)
  • The Wellspring 2017 (55)

Index of Topics

Arthur & Rosalind Eedle's Personal Testimonies Discipleship Expository Items Good and Evil Human Pre-Existance Jane Leade. Philadelphian Numerology in the Bible Quotations from other Authors Resurrection and the Change Ron Wyatt. Archaeology Science Topics The Kingdom of God the Millennium and the Return of Christ The Sabbath Day Universal Reconcilliation

Copyright © 2022 · Website Design and Hosting by Perspective Design